The season premiere generally received positive reviews for its fast pace and its ability to reinvent the show's formula by moving Joe and Love into suburban life.
: Most viewers were shocked by the ending of the first episode, where Love kills their neighbour, Natalie, much earlier than expected. This immediately signaled that the season would not just be a repeat of Joe’s previous obsessions. YOU: 3Г—1
: Critics highly praised the chemistry between Penn Badgley and Victoria Pedretti , noting that they perfectly embody their "mercurial" and toxic characters. Critical Consensus The season premiere generally received positive reviews for