Based on expert reviews and availability, these are the best products to look for:

: While slightly more subtle than other brands, it offers a rich, smoky profile that mimics the flavors found in the restaurant. You can pick this up at Target.

: This is the official retail version of the famous Subway condiment. Reviewers from Tasting Table describe it as a "zesty ranch" with a pepper kick, making it ideal for sandwiches and dipping fries. You can find it at retailers like Kroger and Amazon .

(or its popular variants) at several major retailers and online stores. Top-Rated Store-Bought Options

: A creamier, medium-heat version of the classic hot sauce that is excellent for tacos and elotes. Where to Buy Online

: A highly-rated choice known for its balance of creaminess and spice. It is widely available at Walmart and Target .

: Best for finding larger bottles or June Moon Spice Company specialty batches.